Yes, I suppose it all comes down to dynapink and me having been 'forced' to read each other's stuff here, when we wouldn't normally have done that. On the other hand, I was just about able to believe in her fluffy Ten (because the fic was pretty silly) and her Nine/Rose, and even, just about, her slightly silly Jack, and I suppose I'm just a little bit sad that my Nine didn't work as well for her. But you're right, I shouldn't really expect him to.

And she did say nice stuff about the latter part of the story. :-)

Have you had your feedback back yet? I keep meaning to have a look.